American Staffordshire Terrier vs Scottish Terrier

Which dog breed is right for you?

American Staffordshire Terrier

Size
40–70 lbs, 17–19 in
Lifespan
12–16 years
Exercise
High
Grooming
Low
Good with Kids
Yes
Good with Pets
No
Loyal Courageous Good-natured Smart

Scottish Terrier

Size
19–22 lbs, 10–11 in
Lifespan
12 years
Exercise
Moderate
Grooming
Moderate
Good with Kids
No
Good with Pets
No
Independent Confident Spirited Dignified

About the American Staffordshire Terrier

The American Staffordshire Terrier — often called the AmStaff — was developed in the United States from crosses between Bulldogs and Terriers, earning AKC recognition in 1936. They stand 17–19 inches at the shoulder and weigh 40–70 pounds, presenting a stocky, muscular build that radiates power and confidence. Their short, stiff coat comes in a wide variety of colors and patterns, including blue, fawn, brindle, and black, and requires only minimal grooming.

Temperament & Personality

AmStaffs are known for their courage, intelligence, and unwavering loyalty to their families — they are genuinely affectionate dogs who love being at the center of household activities. They are typically excellent with children and are known for their patience and tolerance with youngsters. Proper socialization from puppyhood is critical, as they can be assertive with other dogs, and their strength demands a handler who can provide calm, confident leadership.

Pros

  • Incredibly loyal and protective of their family without being overly aggressive
  • Smart and highly trainable — they excel in obedience, rally, and therapy work
  • Short coat makes grooming a breeze
  • Sturdy and athletic, perfect for active families who enjoy outdoor activities

Cons

  • May face breed-specific legislation and insurance restrictions
  • Requires early and ongoing socialization with other dogs and animals
  • Prone to hip dysplasia, cardiac disease, and skin allergies
  • Their strong jaws and determination mean they can destroy toys and furniture quickly

AmStaffs make incredible family companions when given the right home — search for adoptable American Staffordshire Terriers on Puplister.

About the Scottish Terrier

The Scottish Terrier — often called the "Scottie" — is one of Scotland's oldest terrier breeds, developed in the Aberdeen area during the 18th and 19th centuries to hunt foxes, badgers, and rats underground. These compact, powerful dogs stand about 10 inches tall and weigh 18 to 22 pounds, with a low center of gravity and surprisingly heavy bone for their size. Their harsh, wiry outer coat and soft, dense undercoat come in black, wheaten, or brindle, and the breed's distinctive profile — long head, erect ears, and bushy eyebrows — is among the most recognizable in dogdom.

Temperament & Personality

Scottish Terriers are independent, dignified, and fiercely loyal to their people — often described as having an "old soul" quality uncommon in the terrier group. They tend to bond most deeply with one or two people and can be reserved or aloof with strangers, making them natural watchdogs. Scotties can be assertive with other dogs, especially those of the same sex, and their strong prey drive means small animals are rarely safe in their presence.

Pros

  • Compact and sturdy — well-suited for apartment living with regular exercise
  • Low-shedding wiry coat when properly maintained through hand-stripping
  • Loyal, devoted companion with a dignified, independent character
  • Excellent watchdog — alert and naturally suspicious of strangers

Cons

  • Stubbornly independent — training requires patience and creative motivation
  • Prone to von Willebrand's disease (a bleeding disorder), Scottie cramp, and bladder cancer
  • Can be aggressive toward other dogs, especially unfamiliar ones
  • Requires regular professional grooming or hand-stripping every 6 to 8 weeks

The Scottish Terrier's unwavering loyalty and distinctive charm are one of a kind — find your Scottie on Puplister.

Available for Adoption

115

American Staffordshire Terriers

Browse

0

Scottish Terriers

Related Articles

All Articles →

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between a American Staffordshire Terrier and a Scottish Terrier?
The American Staffordshire Terrier is 40–70 lbs, 17–19 in sized while the Scottish Terrier is 19–22 lbs, 10–11 in sized. They differ in size (40–70 lbs, 17–19 in vs 19–22 lbs, 10–11 in), lifespan (12–16 years vs 12 years), and care requirements.
Which breed is better with kids, American Staffordshire Terrier or Scottish Terrier?
American Staffordshire Terrier is generally good with kids. Scottish Terrier is not typically good with kids.
Which breed lives longer, American Staffordshire Terrier or Scottish Terrier?
The American Staffordshire Terrier has a lifespan of 12–16 years while the Scottish Terrier has a lifespan of 12 years.

Find Your Perfect Pet

Browse thousands of adoptable pets from shelters near you.

Browse Dogs