What is the difference between a Australian Cattle Dog and a English Setter?

The Australian Cattle Dog is 35–50 lbs, 17–20 in sized while the English Setter is 45–80 lbs, 23–27 in sized. They differ in size (35–50 lbs, 17–20 in vs 45–80 lbs, 23–27 in), lifespan (12–16 years vs 12 years), and care requirements.

Which breed is better with kids, Australian Cattle Dog or English Setter?

Australian Cattle Dog is generally good with kids. English Setter is generally good with kids.

Which breed lives longer, Australian Cattle Dog or English Setter?

The Australian Cattle Dog has a lifespan of 12–16 years while the English Setter has a lifespan of 12 years.

Australian Cattle Dog vs English Setter — Breed Comparison

About the Australian Cattle Dog

The Australian Cattle Dog — also known as the Blue Heeler or Red Heeler — was developed in 19th-century Australia by crossing native Dingoes with Collies and Dalmatians to create the ultimate cattle-herding dog. Compact and muscular, they stand 17–20 inches tall and weigh 35–50 pounds, with a sturdy build designed for all-day work in harsh outback conditions. Their distinctive short double coat comes in two color patterns — blue or blue-mottled and red speckled — and sheds moderately year-round.

Temperament & Personality

Australian Cattle Dogs are intensely loyal, highly intelligent, and tireless workers — they need a job to do or they will invent one, often to their owner's dismay. They bond deeply with one person and can be velcro dogs, following their favorite human everywhere. They are naturally cautious with strangers and may nip at heels — a herding instinct that needs to be redirected — but they are fiercely devoted companions for active owners.

Pros

Exceptionally intelligent and trainable — they excel in agility, herding trials, and obedience
Hardy and healthy with a long lifespan averaging 12–16 years
Compact size makes them manageable while still being robust enough for outdoor work
Low grooming requirements with their short, weather-resistant coat

Cons

Extremely high energy — requires 1–2 hours of vigorous exercise daily
Tendency to nip and herd children, other pets, and even adults
Can become destructive, anxious, or obsessive without adequate mental stimulation
Prone to progressive retinal atrophy, deafness, and hip dysplasia

Think you can keep up with an Australian Cattle Dog? Find your energetic companion on Puplister.

About the English Setter

The English Setter is one of the oldest gun dog breeds — developed in England over 400 years ago to locate game birds by crouching or "setting" to indicate their position. Standing 23–27 inches tall and weighing 45–80 pounds, these graceful dogs are renowned for their beautiful feathered coat in distinctive "belton" patterns — blue belton, orange belton, tricolor, lemon belton, and liver belton. Their elegant appearance, with long, silky ears and a gently flowing coat, has earned them the title of the most beautiful sporting breed.

Temperament & Personality

English Setters are gentle, sweet-natured dogs with a calm indoor demeanor that belies their energetic field abilities. They are exceptionally good with children — patient and tolerant even with rough toddler play — and generally accepting of other dogs and household pets. Their affectionate, people-oriented nature makes them poor kennel dogs; they need to live as part of the family to thrive emotionally.

Pros

One of the gentlest sporting breeds — excellent with children of all ages and other pets
Calm and quiet indoors when given adequate outdoor exercise
Friendly toward strangers — makes a welcoming family dog without guarding tendencies
Versatile field dog that transitions beautifully from hunting companion to couch cuddler

Cons

Feathered coat requires regular grooming — brushing 3–4 times weekly to prevent tangles
Prone to elbow dysplasia, hypothyroidism, and congenital deafness
Strong hunting instincts — will bolt after birds and small animals if not in a secure area
Can be slow to mature mentally — puppy-like behavior often persists until age 3 or beyond

Discover the beauty and gentleness of the English Setter — find one waiting for a home on Puplister.

Australian Cattle Dog vs English Setter